Artist: Seymour Barry ,Fred Fredericks ,Dan Barry "------------------------------- None of the above credits is correct as this one is from Charlton (No. 66).
The Phantom Volume 8 Issue 66 1975-08 25¢ The All New Phantom Charlton Comics
Table Of Contents 01. Front Cover (by Don Sherwood) 02. Advertising 03. The Phantom: Goldbeard the Pirate Editor: George Wildman Writer and Illustrator: Joe Gill / Don Sherwood (?) D-6777
and for the original Indrajal:
Indrajal Comics 250 1976-03-15 The Phantom Goldbeard‘s Strike Force Rs. 1.00 A Times Of India Publication IJC front cover art: n/a
@TPH & @Emile Schwarz : Actually due to shortage of time I had requested MiSD for posting himself, then he started posting. He was worrying about the details. I promised to add/correct details. Since last several weeks I'm very busy, can't post & check regularly as earlier. That's why you had noticed about details. Pls don't mind. IJCs are online due to collective efforts. Information provided by you is most appreciated. Thanks for support & understanding!
Thanks brother I will leave blank in next post you fill the details yourself but I don't understand why people more interested in the details of the comic instead of downloading it
oh dear, for most readers, details are always secondary to comic. the main effort is in scanning and sharing, no two views about it. but hardcore phans do like to gather all the related information to their favourite comics, it is great fun in itself.
this plateform is fast becoming the definitive source of indrajals. sooner or later all 803 published indrajals shall be here in high resolution, that too in multiple languages. my humble request is if any author or artist related information has to be given along with the comic, it should be absolutely correct and checked. won't it be better not to supply any data rather than giving wrong data? please consider, and do not take it otherwise.
I am really surprised at your comment about people being interested in details. Have you seen the database with Emile, even regarding IJCs though he is not even Indian? People like Emile (TPH & I) are interested in the details also along with the comic. Better to leave those details blank rather than give wrong details, even unknowingly.
Venkit you write on my blog that you should thankful to the original scanner Now I ask you that are you thankful to my scans? I don't think you are, because you only criticize my mistakes instead of giving thanks to me. I don't want any thanks and credits from anyone but I want to relies to you that think before writing a comment. I don't post my scans for the credits but only want to share my collection of Indrajal comics to others because I didn't found good scans of Indrajal on any blog that's why I start scanning. And I already mentioned to PBC That in next post I leave those details blank. then why you suggesting me again what is the problem with you?
I do not want to turn this into a he-said he-said sort of a feud. I have none against you any one else. But I would like to answer some of what u claim I did.
01.Your words "Venkit you write on my blog that you should thankful to the original scanner Now I ask you that are you thankful to my scans? I don't think you are, because you only criticize my mistakes instead of giving thanks to me. I don't want any thanks and credits from anyone but I want to relies to you that think before writing a comment." I stand by my words. If you post something that you have not spent even a millisecond of your time scanning or editing, I strongly feel that you have to say truthfully that you are indebted to so-and-so for the scans. If you do not know the details of the original scanner, you should at least acknowledge your gratitude to the unknown scanner and not create the false impression that you did the hard work. As regards not expressing my thanks to your scans, please refer to the post in this same blog. http://indrajal-online.blogspot.com/2011/11/200-1974-ratmen-of-rodencia-219-1974.html. Just because you post so many things, it does not mean that I have to download them all and say thanks. The simple reason being, those comics do not interest me. It has always been my policy to put in a word of thanks as soon as I download anything that interests me.
02. Your words " I don't post my scans for the credits but only want to share my collection of Indrajal comics to others because I didn't found good scans of Indrajal on any blog that's why I start scanning." These words just like "I don't understand why people more interested in the details of the comic instead of downloading it" in your previous note is a sweeping condemnation of whoever that does not think the same way you do. People have been scanning IJCs for the sake of sharing, right from 2005. In this blog itself we have been able to put up nearly 400-500 comics in HQ since 2008. There are a lot of other bloggers who have been posting HQ scans in their blogs. So your assertion that you didn't find good scans of IJC on any blog, is either disingenuous or childish.
03. I have no feud with you or any other person. There may be differences of opinion and I think we should be mature to discuss those in a grown up manner. I am stopping any further comments in the matter irrespective of what kind of immature reaction is there to this note.
Thanks for all of your original posts that I have downloaded.
It's your blog's rule that you give credit to every scanner and give details of every comic but you cannot see any details of any comics or credits on my blog and I did not put my MiSD signature on any others scan I did't want any other person's credit I regard them and I know how hard it is to scan a comic so please don't discus this matter further
"
ReplyDeleteScript: Lee Falk
Artist: Seymour Barry ,Fred Fredericks ,Dan Barry "-------------------------------
None of the above credits is correct as this one is from Charlton (No. 66).
Thanks for posting this High Resolution version.
TPh
Hi,
ReplyDeletehere are data for the original Charlton:
The Phantom
Volume 8
Issue 66
1975-08
25¢
The All New Phantom
Charlton Comics
Table Of Contents
01. Front Cover (by Don Sherwood)
02. Advertising
03. The Phantom: Goldbeard the Pirate
Editor: George Wildman
Writer and Illustrator: Joe Gill / Don Sherwood (?)
D-6777
and for the original Indrajal:
Indrajal Comics 250
1976-03-15
The Phantom
Goldbeard‘s Strike Force
Rs. 1.00
A Times Of India Publication
IJC front cover art: n/a
Thanks a lot for this IJC. Also thanks to Emile Schwarz to provide detailed basic informations.
ReplyDeleteCover art - Govind Brahmania, the legendary cover artist of Indrajal Comics.
ReplyDelete@TPH & @Emile Schwarz : Actually due to shortage of time I had requested MiSD for posting himself, then he started posting. He was worrying about the details. I promised to add/correct details. Since last several weeks I'm very busy, can't post & check regularly as earlier. That's why you had noticed about details.
ReplyDeletePls don't mind.
IJCs are online due to collective efforts. Information provided by you is most appreciated.
Thanks for support & understanding!
Thanks brother I will leave blank in next post you fill the details yourself but I don't understand why people more interested in the details of the comic instead of downloading it
ReplyDeleteoh dear, for most readers, details are always secondary to comic. the main effort is in scanning and sharing, no two views about it. but hardcore phans do like to gather all the related information to their favourite comics, it is great fun in itself.
ReplyDeletethis plateform is fast becoming the definitive source of indrajals. sooner or later all 803 published indrajals shall be here in high resolution, that too in multiple languages. my humble request is if any author or artist related information has to be given along with the comic, it should be absolutely correct and checked. won't it be better not to supply any data rather than giving wrong data? please consider, and do not take it otherwise.
Thank you MiSd & Prabhat!
ReplyDeleteI am really surprised at your comment about people being interested in details. Have you seen the database with Emile, even regarding IJCs though he is not even Indian? People like Emile (TPH & I) are interested in the details also along with the comic. Better to leave those details blank rather than give wrong details, even unknowingly.
ReplyDeleteVenkit you write on my blog that you should thankful to the original scanner Now I ask you that are you thankful to my scans? I don't think you are, because you only criticize my mistakes instead of giving thanks to me. I don't want any thanks and credits from anyone but I want to relies to you that think before writing a comment. I don't post my scans for the credits but only want to share my collection of Indrajal comics to others because I didn't found good scans of Indrajal on any blog that's why I start scanning. And I already mentioned to PBC That in next post I leave those details blank. then why you suggesting me again what is the problem with you?
ReplyDeleteI do not want to turn this into a he-said he-said sort of a feud. I have none against you any one else. But I would like to answer some of what u claim I did.
ReplyDelete01.Your words "Venkit you write on my blog that you should thankful to the original scanner Now I ask you that are you thankful to my scans? I don't think you are, because you only criticize my mistakes instead of giving thanks to me. I don't want any thanks and credits from anyone but I want to relies to you that think before writing a comment."
I stand by my words. If you post something that you have not spent even a millisecond of your time scanning or editing, I strongly feel that you have to say truthfully that you are indebted to so-and-so for the scans. If you do not know the details of the original scanner, you should at least acknowledge your gratitude to the unknown scanner and not create the false impression that you did the hard work.
As regards not expressing my thanks to your scans, please refer to the post in this same blog.
http://indrajal-online.blogspot.com/2011/11/200-1974-ratmen-of-rodencia-219-1974.html.
Just because you post so many things, it does not mean that I have to download them all and say thanks. The simple reason being, those comics do not interest me. It has always been my policy to put in a word of thanks as soon as I download anything that interests me.
02. Your words " I don't post my scans for the credits but only want to share my collection of Indrajal comics to others because I didn't found good scans of Indrajal on any blog that's why I start scanning."
These words just like "I don't understand why people more interested in the details of the comic instead of downloading it" in your previous note is a sweeping condemnation of whoever that does not think the same way you do.
People have been scanning IJCs for the sake of sharing, right from 2005. In this blog itself we have been able to put up nearly 400-500 comics in HQ since 2008. There are a lot of other bloggers who have been posting HQ scans in their blogs. So your assertion that you didn't find good scans of IJC on any blog, is either disingenuous or childish.
03. I have no feud with you or any other person. There may be differences of opinion and I think we should be mature to discuss those in a grown up manner. I am stopping any further comments in the matter irrespective of what kind of immature reaction is there to this note.
Thanks for all of your original posts that I have downloaded.
It's your blog's rule that you give credit to every scanner and give details of every comic but you cannot see any details of any comics or credits on my blog and I did not put my MiSD signature on any others scan I did't want any other person's credit I regard them and I know how hard it is to scan a comic so please don't discus this matter further
ReplyDelete